I say to him, it’s been a year, and he looks at me across the table with its fake spider plant and starts talking about how he’s found a simple way to make lemon trees grow in the shade, like he didn’t text me an hour ago after 371 days of no contact, asking me to drop everything and meet him at Roast, and of course I did because I know through a friend of a friend that his mom just died. And so, I skipped a weekly meeting with my department head and took a Blue Bike in the wrong shoes to witness him in mourning because it’s what I deserve, to see him low, lower than I was when he left me on read, and be given the choice of whether to help him stand again or leave him as he was, but I’d never imagine lemon trees so, of course, it throws me. There’s a bit of egg hanging on to a mole on his cheek, just out of reach of his tongue, and I don’t tell him to get it, and I don’t wipe it off myself, even though I’d be absolutely annihilated if I knew that someone I was once in awe of saw it and did nothing. This is not because I’m in awe of him anymore, but rather, because I’ve experienced that sort of epiphany firsthand: how all the seriousness and subject matter expertise in the world on second-wave feminism can be diminished by a bit of spinach or a sesame seed or, in this case, egg and so I let it diminish him. There’s a woman next to us who’s seen the egg though, I know she’s seen it, and a part of me worries this witness will say something, but we’re on the same page and she returns to her Anna Karenina. He keeps talking about how he spliced a lemon tree with a fern and thickened its skin with alligator genes, for a moment, I wish that I had the sort of palate that craved lemon slices beneath chicken skin so I could say he did all that work in his little white coat for me, that he loves a metaphor as a substitute for feeling, but I don’t like lemons and I’m annoyed that I’m here again, unpacking his symbolism for free and that I still have his number memorized even though I deleted it and couldn’t even text sorry who is this when his message first came through like I’d rehearsed but that was also because he actually used the word emergency. My tired fantasy of an ending I deserve, like all the others before it (sending a love letter to me in the mail or asking for forgiveness in an overlong voice note and begging for me back just so I could have a choice in it all), is not coming true. I will not get the chance to say, I’m sorry your mom died but you made sure I never met her, and so, yeah, we’re not getting back together, because the emergency he mentioned is not, in fact, about her or us or, maybe even, about him. The bit of egg wags on his face and he asks me, So, can you take them? And I say, Take what? And he’s like, the lemon trees, they don’t need much, just water once every two weeks, just until Fall. Did you bring your car? and I see sparks on Roast’s stained-wood walls and I can picture a forest of them, fragrant and oily, ready to be scraped raw, and my voice catches on something sharp in my chest because he thinks I’m still in the same place that he left me, that he thinks I’ve already said yes, that the part of his brain that plays God with vegetation saw nothing wrong with reaching out to someone who couldn’t keep a plant alive to save her life, a someone he discarded, with an open-ended babysitting opportunity. Even in our play-pretend world that was alive and well 380 days ago, I was never that person and all the imagination I wasted on him since he stopped talking to me vibrates through my nailbeds. Maybe I should take those useless plants and burn them in effigy for closure and inhale their fragrant crisping wood to cleanse me of him like good sage. I exhale hard enough for both him and the woman with her Russian literature to notice and lean away and I think about this man who, last August, would still not have called me first about his mom, and it’s then and there that I decide I need something to survive me, a sign of life after all of this that is also an ending I deserve, and so I say, carefully, slowly, I’ll think about it. But, you know, I’ll probably kill them and the second I say it, death is at the table and something around his eyebrows crumples and he leans forward, the egg on his cheek just in swiping distance and my stomach swells because yes, this is the way I did picture it at last, him reaching for me as I walk away, and as I press my hands down to stand up, to leave him here at last, he grabs my fingers in his clammy palm, and says, I‘ll solve for that next. I promise, I just need more time.
Salena Casha’s work has appeared in over 180 publications in the last decade. Recent pieces can be found with HAD, F(r)iction, and The Forge. She survives New England winters on good beer and black coffee. Subscribe to her substack at salenacasha.substack.com











